Learn: Crafting High-Performance Systems

Concept-focused guide for Crafting High-Performance Systems (no answers revealed).

~7 min read

Overview

Welcome! In this deep-dive, we'll unravel the essential concepts and strategies behind building high-performance systems, with a strong focus on minimizing latency—whether in memory, disk, CPU, network, or distributed architectures. You'll learn how to analyze, measure, and optimize latency across different system layers, and how to choose appropriate technologies and techniques to achieve responsiveness at scale. By the end, you'll be able to reason about system bottlenecks, apply practical optimization methods, and avoid common pitfalls in crafting low-latency, high-throughput solutions.


Concept-by-Concept Deep Dive

1. Understanding and Measuring Latency

Latency is the delay between a request and its corresponding response. In high-performance systems, latency affects user experience, system throughput, and scalability.

Types of Latency

  • Memory Access Latency: Time taken to fetch data from memory hierarchy (cache, RAM, disk).
  • Disk Access Latency: Delay in reading or writing data from/to disk storage.
  • Network Transfer Latency: The round-trip time for data to traverse between systems or services.
  • CPU Process Latency: Time a process waits to get CPU time and execute.

Latency Measurement Metrics

  • Mean/Median Latency: Average or middle value of observed latencies.
  • Percentile Latency (e.g., p95/p99): Latency below which a certain percentage of requests fall—crucial for understanding "tail latencies."
  • Throughput: Amount of work done per unit time, often linked to but distinct from latency.
  • Round Trip Time (RTT): Particularly important for network and distributed systems.

Reasoning About Latency

  • Always distinguish between average and worst-case (tail) latencies.
  • Use appropriate tools (profilers, tracing, custom metrics) to gather and interpret latency data.

Common Misconceptions

  • Myth: Improving average latency always improves user experience.
    Fix: Focus on tail latencies, which often drive user-perceived slowness.
  • Myth: High throughput means low latency.
    Fix: Systems can be high-throughput but still laggy for individual requests.

2. Caching and Memory Optimization

Caching is a core technique to reduce memory and disk latency by storing frequently accessed data in faster storage layers.

Cache Hierarchy

  • L1/L2/L3 CPU Caches: Closest to the processor, smallest and fastest.
  • RAM: Larger but slower compared to CPU caches.
  • Persistent Caches (e.g., Redis, Memcached): Used for larger, distributed workloads.

Cache Replacement Policies

  • Least Recently Used (LRU): Removes data that hasn't been accessed for the longest time.
  • Least Frequently Used (LFU): Removes data accessed the least number of times.
  • First-In, First-Out (FIFO): Removes data in the order it arrived.
  • Random Replacement: Removes items randomly.

Optimizing Cache Utilization

  • Match cache replacement policy to data access patterns (e.g., temporal vs. frequency locality).
  • Monitor cache hit/miss ratios to tune cache size and policy.

Common Misconceptions

  • Myth: Bigger caches always mean better performance.
    Fix: Oversized caches can waste resources and may not fit working sets efficiently.
  • Myth: Any replacement policy will do.
    Fix: The wrong policy can cause frequent evictions of "hot" data, increasing misses.

3. Disk and Storage Latency Minimization

Disk access latency can be a major bottleneck, especially in I/O-bound systems.

Storage Technologies

  • HDDs: Mechanical, higher latency.
  • SSDs: Flash-based, much lower latency.
  • In-memory Databases: Store all data in RAM for fastest access.

Strategies for Reducing Disk Latency

  • Data Locality: Place data closer to where it will be accessed.
  • Caching frequently read files: Use memory or distributed caches to serve hot data.
  • Sharding/Partitioning: Distribute data to reduce contention and parallelize access.
  • Pre-fetching: Load anticipated data into memory before it's needed.

Data Integrity Considerations

  • Use replication, checksums, and transactional writes to prevent data corruption during optimization.

Common Misconceptions

  • Myth: Moving all data to SSDs eliminates latency.
    Fix: SSDs help, but network, CPU, and software overheads can still dominate.

4. Reducing Network and Distributed System Latency

In distributed applications, network round-trip times and serialization of requests often dominate end-to-end latency.

Network Latency Optimizations

  • Geographic Distribution: Place servers and data close to users (edge computing, CDNs).
  • Protocol Optimization: Reduce overhead with lightweight protocols or persistent connections.
  • Batching and Compression: Send multiple requests/data in one go, or compress payloads to minimize transfer size.
  • Connection Pooling: Reuse TCP connections to avoid handshake overheads.

Synchronization in Distributed Databases

  • Use eventual consistency or conflict-free replicated data types (CRDTs) for lower synchronization delays.
  • Leverage leaderless or multi-leader replication for faster writes/reads.

Measuring and Decomposing Latency

  • Serial Latency: When requests must be processed in sequence, total latency is the sum of each step.
  • Parallel Latency: When operations run concurrently, total latency is the duration of the slowest branch.

Common Misconceptions

  • Myth: One fast server can serve a global user base quickly.
    Fix: Physical distance imposes speed-of-light limits; distribute presence globally.

5. CPU and Process Scheduling Latency

CPU process latency is crucial for systems reliant on fast computation and context switching.

Context Switching

  • Happens when the CPU switches from one process or thread to another.
  • High context-switch rates can degrade latency due to cache invalidation and scheduler overhead.

Minimizing CPU Latency

  • Use asynchronous or event-driven models to reduce blocking.
  • Pin threads to CPU cores to minimize cache misses.
  • Optimize workload distribution to avoid CPU starvation.

Common Misconceptions

  • Myth: More threads always improve performance.
    Fix: Too many threads can increase context switching overhead, hurting latency.

Worked Examples (generic)

Example 1: Calculating Serial Service Latency

Setup:
A request must pass through three services (A → B → C), each adding 100ms processing time.
Process:

  • Total latency = Latency of A + Latency of B + Latency of C
  • Substitute values symbolically:
    Total latency = Ta + Tb + Tc
  • If each is 100ms: Total latency = 100ms + 100ms + 100ms = 300ms

Example 2: Evaluating Network Latency Reduction

Setup:
A web service serves users in Asia from a server in the US. Users experience high latency.
Process:

  • Problem: High round-trip time due to geographic distance.
  • Solution: Deploy a CDN node in Asia.
  • Reasoning: Requests are served from the nearest edge location, reducing latency by minimizing physical distance.

Example 3: Optimizing Cache Policy

Setup:
An application frequently accesses a small subset of data repeatedly, with occasional bursts of access to other items.
Process:

  • Choose a cache replacement policy that prioritizes recently accessed data.
  • Monitor cache hit/miss statistics after deploying the policy.
  • Adjust as data access patterns evolve.

Common Pitfalls and Fixes

  • Ignoring Tail Latency: Always consider high-percentile latencies, not just averages.
  • Over-caching or Under-caching: Match cache size and policy to actual working set; monitor and adjust regularly.
  • Assuming Hardware Solves All Problems: Fast disks or CPUs help, but software and network design often matter more.
  • Chain Serialization: Serial dependencies between services add up; parallelize or batch requests where possible.
  • Neglecting Network Geography: Serve content from locations close to users; global users can't be efficiently served from a single region.
  • Using Synchronous Calls Everywhere: Prefer async communication when possible to avoid blocking.

Summary

  • Latency optimization requires understanding and measuring delays across memory, disk, network, and CPU.
  • Choose cache replacement policies and storage technologies that match your application's data access patterns.
  • Always consider both average and tail latencies for user experience.
  • Reduce disk and network latency by leveraging caching, geographic distribution, and protocol optimization.
  • Serial dependencies add directly to latency; parallelize when possible.
  • Regularly monitor, profile, and adjust system design to address evolving bottlenecks.